Gideon's Bakehouse at Disney Springs has been incredibly popular since it opened, with waits of up to five hours on the weekends just to grab some of these delectable delights. Of course, we had to see what all the hype was about for ourselves so we popped over to Disney Springs on a Monday morning around opening and hopped in line. Waits are much shorter midweek and earlier in the day, with the virtual queue not even being in use yet, our wait was about an hour.
It was a sunny morning and there isn't much shade in line, so definitely be prepared for some Florida elements. Soon I was rounding the corner and got my first glimpse of the bake shop, which looks quite unassuming from the exterior.
Once inside, the vibe completely changes. It's dark and a little spooky, but in the best way. Halloween is my favorite so I was definitely loving the vibes and all about it.
The almost-half-pound cookies and huge cake slices are on display as you walk up so you can get an idea of what you might want to order. It was October so the seasonal cookies were Frankenstein and Bride of Frankenstein. Cookies will run you $6 each while the cake slices are $9 each. We were in a cookie mood this morning so I got a box of six cookies to take home and got five different flavors to try.
Original Chocolate Chip Cookie
The Gideon's Original Chocolate Chip is the foundation of who we are, the first child. This recipe took 15 years to perfect and is filled with history. It is packed inside and out with a variety of Chocolates, infused with differing vanillas, and has a texture that might almost trick you into thinking you're eating Cookie Dough. This Cookie has been named everything from Best in Orlando to Best on Planet Earth, and we couldn't be prouder to hand make it from scratch for you daily.
We are very picky with our chocolate chip cookies, and this was quite delicious. I loved how many chocolate chips there were! For a classic cookie lover, you really can't go wrong here.
Triple Chocolate Chip
Our Triple Chocolate (which is really five kinds of chocolate) is made with fancy Callebaut and Ghirardelli chocolates, to name a few. To make it extra velvety, we pour our chocolate ganache straight into the cookie dough as we're mixing it. This is the Cookie you just want to curl up with, our most emotional Cookie.
Chocolate fans unite! This is decadent and delightful. The little flakes of salt pair so beautifully to bring out the chocolatey goodness here. This is definitely rich but oh boy did I love it!
The Frankenstein is a Halloween month celebration, made from pieces parts of all the candies you want in your bag, and topped with M&M’s that we lovingly place on the top to be sure you get all the colors. Break it open and you’ll find crushed Oreo Double Stuff and Chocolate Pieces.
A new flavor, created to give companionship to the Frankenstein, the Bride of Frankenstein arrives!! This almost 1/2 pound monster of a Cookie is created in the same mold as the Frank Cookie but features White Chocolate, Golden Oreos, and M&M’s!
These were both super fun! Each bite was an exciting new adventure with so many different flavors stuffed into each cookie. These are definitely worth checking out if you are visiting in the month of October.
Peanut Butter Crunch
This Cookie took an extra-long time to perfect. We wanted you to enjoy something that was truly set apart from the standard flavor for a PB cookie. We're very proud that our Peanut Butter Crunch is entirely peanut buttery with every bite. Not surprising since the dough is made of mostly peanut butter! It's topped with our handmade candied peanuts for the perfect amount of crunch. A must for any PB Lover.
This might have actually been my favorite of the bunch! The saltiness of the peanuts with the sweetness of the cookie was just a perfect pairing for me. A good peanut butter cookie is so hard to come by so this was such a delightful surprise.